Our Menu
Appetizers
Old Town Chili
$9.75/Cup
$15.00/Bowl
With cool cheddar, diced onions, and sour cream.
Soups
$7.50/Cup
$11.50/Bowl
Made here daily (See Daily Specials)
Crispy Spuds
$15.75
Thick cut slices of jacket potato, fried to perfection with a side of homemade horseradish and cheddar dip.
Fried Calamari
$22.25
With spicy cocktail sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Wings
$17.50/Small (7-8 wings)
$24.50/Large (15-16 wings)
With blue cheese dressing and celery sticks. • Extra Bleu Cheese +$1.00 | Extra Wing Sauce +$2.50
Fried Clam Strips
$21.50
With caper tartar sauce.
Nachos
$22.75
Served with old-town chili, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream, and salsa | Same price for meatless option with guacamole.
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers $18.25 | Buffalo Style $22.00 • With honey mustard or BBQ sauce.
Cheese Quesadilla
$17.00
Chicken Quesadilla
$19.50
Giant German Pretzel
$14.50
Served with mustard • Add Cheese Sauce +$4.00
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$19.75
Served with pita chips.
Mozzarella Sticks
$16.50
Served with marinara sauce.
Zucchini Fritte
$17.00
Served with chipotle ranch sauce.
Macaroni & Cheese Balls
$17.25
Served with marinara sauce.
Guacamole & Chips
$19.50
Homemade Pierogis
$20.50
Served with grilled onions, applesauce, and sour cream.
Salads
Our Dressings: Vinaigrette, Southwestern Ranch, Russian, Creamy Garlic and Cracked Peppercorn, Olive Oil and Red Wine Vinegar, Bleu Cheese (+$1.25)
House Salad
$11.00
Shredded carrots and red cabbage, served atop a bed of mixed greens.
Caesar Salad
$19.00
Parmesan cheese, croutons, and anchovies served atop Romaine lettuce with garlic-anchovy dressing • Add Chicken Breast +$7.50
Club Salad
$25.25
Grilled chicken breast, crisp bacon, Swiss cheese, and tomatoes in mixed greens.
Chef Salad
$23.50
Smoked turkey, Swiss cheese, crumbled bacon, red onion, and hard-boiled egg, served atop a bed of mixed greens.
Steak Salad
$26.00
Marinated steak, thinly sliced and grilled medium rare, with grated cheese, red onion, and tomatoes, served atop a bed of mixed greens with a side of pita bread.
Cobb Salad
$24.00
Alfalfa, avocado, olives, egg, and bacon on a bed of mixed greens.
Old Town Burgers
*All burgers include your choice of Fries, Homemade Potato Salad, or Coleslaw | Onion Rings +$3.00 • Add Extra: Bacon, Roasted Onions, Mushrooms, Chili +$3.75 | Blue Cheese Dressing +$1.00
Hamburger Platter
$19.50
New York Times Gourmet Magazine's “Best of New York City” is grilled to your liking and served with lettuce, tomato, and onion in a soft sesame seed bun. Please ask for mayonnaise or mustard when you order.
Hamburger
$19.50
The Mayor's choice | Bloomberg
Cheeseburger
$21.00
Choice of American, Swiss, Muenster, or Cheddar.
Bisonburger
$23.25
Grass-fed.
Turkey Burger
$21.25
Ground turkey seasoned with our special blend of onions and herbs.
Beyond Burger
$19.25
Plant-based meat substitute patty.
"Pueblo Viejo" Burger
$24.25
Cheddar burger with guacamole & buffalo sauce
Hot Sandwiches
*All sandwiches include your choice of fries, homemade potato salad, or coleslaw. Substitute Onion Rings: +$3.50
Tuna Melt
$20.25
Our tuna salad and cheddar cheese are served cool-in-the-middle on a toasted Thomas’ English Mun.
Clam Roll
$21.75
Fried clam strips in a grilled roll with tartar sauce.
Fish Sandwich
$21.75
Fried ounder with lettuce, tomato, and red onion, on a toasted club roll, served with tartar sauce.
Chicken BLT
$23.75
Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and garlic mayo on a Ciabatta roll.
Frankfurters
$12.75/One Frank
$19.25/Two Franks
New York Times Gourmet Magazine “Best of NYC” all-beef frank on a grilled roll.
Chili Dog
$21.75
All beef frank, topped with a scoop of chili, chopped onions, and grated cheddar cheese, on a grilled bun.
Sliced Steak Sandwich
$26.00
Ank steak, provolone cheese, with a choice of mushrooms or grilled onions, served on a toasted hero.
Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich
$23.75
Buttermilk chicken topped with 'slaw, jalapeños, & chipotle mayo, on a tasted bun
Cold Sandwiches
All sandwiches include your choice of fries, homemade potato salad, or coleslaw | Substitute onion rings: +$3.00 • All sandwiches come with lettuce and tomato | *Please ask for mayonnaise or mustard when you order.
B.L.T.
$19.25
Bacon, lettuce, and tomatoes on white toast.
Tuna Salad
$19.50
Chunk light tuna and fresh dill on whole wheat bread.
Smoked Turkey
$20.75
Turkey with bacon and muenster cheese on white toast.
Liverwurst
$19.00
With muenster cheese, and red onion on rye bread.
Grilled Sandwiches
All sandwiches include your choice of fries, homemade potato salad, or coleslaw | Substitute onion rings: +$3.00
Sautéed mushrooms and Munster cheese on pumpernickel bread
$19.25
(Former Governor Pataki’s choice)
American cheese, crispy bacon, and tomatoes on white bread
$20.25
Crisp bacon and cheddar cheese on rye bread with grainy mustard
$20.25
Smoked turkey reuben with Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on Rye bread
$22.25
Old Town Sides
Fresh Cut Shoestring Fries
$9.25/Small
$12.50/Large
New Potato Salad
$9.00/Small
$11.50/Large
With hard-boiled egg and red onion.
Coleslaw
$8.25/Small
$11.25/Large
Baked Potato
$7.25
With sour cream and sweet butter.
Onion Rings
$15.75
Desserts
Warm Strudel
$15.25
With vanilla ice cream.
Molten Lava Cake
$15.25
With vanilla ice cream.